When, where and how
कब, कहाँ एवं कैसे — तिथियाँ एक ढाँचा हैं, एवं ढाँचा किसी ने बनाया
What CBSE puts in the first chapter of History, and why it is first
> When, where and how — the sources of history · dates and the problem of dating · periodisation · the places the past happened in.
This chapter is not an introduction to be hurried through. It is the chapter in which the child is told how anybody knows any of this, and everything in the other twenty-three depends on it. A class VI child arrives believing that history is a list of things that happened, written down at the time by someone who was there. Almost none of it is.
WHERE the past happened. Early human history in the subcontinent clusters where people could live: along rivers — the Narmada, the Sindhu (Indus) and its tributaries, the Ganga and Yamuna — and in areas where wild wheat, barley, rice and grazing were available. The Sulaiman and Kirthar hills to the north-west are where sheep and goat rearing began; the Garo hills and the Vindhyas are early rice and agriculture areas. Geography is not the backdrop to this history; it is one of its causes — which is the first quiet demonstration that History and Geography are one subject.
WHEN it happened, and the honest difficulty. Dates in early history are approximate and argued over. A child should learn early that "about 2000 years ago" is often a more truthful statement than a precise year, and that historians write c. (circa, "about") in front of a date to say so.
The counting convention, which CTET asks about directly. BC = Before Christ, AD = Anno Domini ("in the year of the Lord"). Because that naming is tied to one religion, scholars increasingly write BCE (Before Common Era) and CE (Common Era) for exactly the same years — 1500 BC and 1500 BCE are the same date. BP means "Before Present". And the counting runs backwards before the changeover: 300 BCE is earlier than 100 BCE, which is the single commonest arithmetic error children make in this subject.
कब, कहाँ एवं कैसे — तिथियाँ एक ढाँचा हैं, एवं ढाँचा किसी ने बनाया
HOW we know — the sources, and the frame somebody built
THE SOURCES, and what each one can and cannot tell you.
Put those limits together and you have the discipline's central honesty: we know most about those who wrote, ruled, built in stone and were buried with goods, and least about everybody else — labourers, most women, forest peoples, the poor. That is not a gap in the child's textbook. It is a gap in the evidence itself, and saying so is the difference between teaching history and reciting it.
AND THE FRAME — periodisation, which CTET asks about. Dividing the past into periods is necessary and is never neutral. In 1817 the British writer James Mill published A History of British India and divided the subcontinent's past into three periods — Hindu, Muslim and British. That scheme is rejected by historians today for a specific reason worth stating plainly: it labels whole centuries by the religion of whoever ruled, treats each period as internally uniform, and implies the third period was an improvement. "Ancient, medieval and modern" replaced those names and inherited the shape, and historians disagree about whether even those three labels fit the subcontinent, since "medieval" was coined for European history. A period is a tool somebody made for a purpose, and the tool can be argued with.
कब, कहाँ एवं कैसे — तिथियाँ एक ढाँचा हैं, एवं ढाँचा किसी ने बनाया
In the classroom
A class VI teacher in Madhubani is on the first chapter of Our Pasts I. She has the textbook, a blackboard, and a one-rupee coin.
Scene 1 — she does not begin with dates. She holds up the coin and asks: "Suppose everything else about today vanished, and a thousand years from now somebody found only this. What could they work out about us?" The class produces a great deal: the language and script, that we used metal money, the year, the Ashoka lions, that the state existed and made things. Then the harder half: "What could they NOT work out?" Somebody says what we ate. Somebody says who was poor. The class has just built the sources card by itself, and it took eight minutes.
Scene 2 — the number line that fixes the arithmetic. She draws a long line, marks 0 near the right, and writes today's year at the far right. "Numbers to the left of zero count backwards." Three children come up and place 300 BCE, 100 BCE and 200 CE. The first attempt puts 300 BCE to the right of 100 BCE, which is the error she was hunting, and she does not correct it — she asks the class to check with the line. The line settles it without her.
Scene 3 — the periodisation question, asked as a question. She writes on the board: Hindu period · Muslim period · British period, and says these were the names a British writer gave in 1817. "What do you notice about how the first two are named, and the third?" A boy says the first two are religions and the third is a country. That is the entire critique, produced by a twelve-year-old in one sentence, and it lands because he found it rather than read it.
Scene 4 — she is careful to be fair. She adds that dividing time into periods has to be done by somebody — even "ancient, medieval, modern" is a choice, and historians argue about whether "medieval", a word invented for Europe, fits here at all. She does not leave the class with the impression that naming periods is a trick, only that it is a decision with reasons behind it that can be examined.
Scene 5 — the homework that makes the point stick. Ask the oldest person in your house about one thing that happened before you were born. Write what they say. Then write one thing you would want to check, and how you could check it. Next day the class has thirty oral sources and thirty checks — and a working understanding of why a historian never rests on a single account.
कब, कहाँ एवं कैसे — तिथियाँ एक ढाँचा हैं, एवं ढाँचा किसी ने बनाया
Commonly said, and wrong
"History is what happened." History is what can be shown to have happened, from evidence that survived. Those are not the same, and the gap between them is the subject. Most of what happened left no trace at all, and what survived survived unevenly — stone outlasts cloth, temples outlast huts, and the writings of the literate few outlast the thoughts of everybody else.
"300 BCE is after 100 BCE because 300 is bigger." The commonest arithmetic error in the subject. Before the changeover the count runs backwards, so 300 BCE is earlier. A number line drawn once, with zero on it, prevents this for good — and it is the same number line the maths module uses for integers, which is worth saying to the children out loud.
"BC and BCE are different dates." They are the same years under different names. BC/AD names the scale after one religion's founder; BCE/CE keeps the identical numbering and drops that naming. 1500 BC = 1500 BCE. Nothing about the date changes.
"Inscriptions are reliable because they are carved in stone, so they cannot be altered." Hard to alter is not the same as impartial. Nearly every inscription was commissioned by a ruler, a donor or a wealthy household, and records what that person wanted recorded. Its durability makes it a good source about what the powerful claimed, which is a genuinely useful thing to know and is not the same as what occurred.
"Archaeology gives us the plain facts, without anyone's opinion." Archaeology gives objects, and objects have to be interpreted by somebody. A row of large houses and a row of small ones is a fact; "this society was unequal" is a reading of that fact. The reading is where the historian enters, and it is where two historians can honestly differ.
"The textbook's account is THE account." It is a selection made by a committee with limited pages, and where historians disagree it usually reports one reading. Saying so does not undermine the book — it teaches the child what a book of history is, which is the whole point of this chapter.
"Mill's Hindu–Muslim–British scheme was simply wrong and can be ignored." It was influential, which is why it is taught: much of how the subcontinent's past was written for a century took its shape from it, and "ancient–medieval–modern" inherited that shape. Knowing where a frame came from is part of knowing how to use it.
कब, कहाँ एवं कैसे — तिथियाँ एक ढाँचा हैं, एवं ढाँचा किसी ने बनाया
Points to Remember