The Heinz Dilemma
Heinz's wife is dying. A chemist has the one drug that could save her and charges far more than Heinz can pay. Heinz breaks in and steals it. Was he right?
Lawrence Kohlberg put stories like this to children and adults. The key point: he did not score the yes or the no. He studied the reasoning behind it.
Two people can give the same answer from very different moral stages. One says stealing is wrong because of jail. Another says it is wrong because laws hold society together.
1. When studying answers to the Heinz dilemma, Kohlberg was most interested in:
2. A child says, 'I will not copy in the test because the teacher will punish me.' Which stage is this?
3. A boy shares his lunch so that classmates will call him a good friend. Which stage is this?
4. 'I will help you with your homework if you lend me your bicycle.' This reasoning belongs to:
5. A citizen says, 'Everyone must follow the law, or society will fall apart.' This reflects:
6. Who criticised Kohlberg's theory for favouring male ways of moral reasoning?
7. How many levels and stages does Kohlberg's theory have?
8. Which classroom practice best supports moral development in Kohlberg's view?