Why Judges Needed Doctrines
The Constitution says what Parliament and the state legislatures may do, but it rarely says what happens when a law goes slightly too far. Is the whole Act dead? Does an old colonial law vanish on 26 January 1950? Which list does a law belong to when it touches two subjects at once?
The Supreme Court answered these questions case by case, and the answers hardened into doctrines: short rules of interpretation, each with a name, a leading case and usually an Article behind it.
For exams this is a perfect matching topic. A paper gives you a doctrine and asks for its case, or describes a situation and asks which doctrine applies. Learn each doctrine as a triangle with three corners: the one-line idea, the Article it hangs on, and the case that announced it. This short builds those triangles one by one, then shows you where the papers set their traps.
1. Under which doctrine does a court strike down only the unconstitutional part of a law and let the rest of the Act survive?
2. The Doctrine of Eclipse was laid down by the Supreme Court in which case?
3. The maxim 'what cannot be done directly cannot be done indirectly' expresses which doctrine?
4. The Doctrine of Pith and Substance is mainly used to decide:
5. The Doctrine of Prospective Overruling was first applied in India in which case?
6. Which Article settles a conflict between a Union law and a State law on a Concurrent List subject?
7. In which case did the Supreme Court hold that a citizen cannot waive a Fundamental Right?
8. The Doctrine of Eclipse applies to which kind of law?