Why Property Became a Battleground
When the Constitution came into force in 1950, property was a fundamental right in two places. Article 19(1)(f) gave every citizen the right to acquire, hold and dispose of property, and Article 31 said that property could be taken by the state only by law and with compensation.
At the same time, the new government had promised land reform: ending zamindari, fixing ceilings on landholdings and giving land to the tiller. Every such law took property from someone. Landowners went to court, arguing that the laws violated their fundamental right, and several courts agreed.
What followed was a long contest between Parliament, which kept amending the Constitution to save land reform, and the Supreme Court, which kept asking how far Parliament could go. The contest ended in 1978, when property was removed from the list of fundamental rights.
This case is worth studying because it produced some of the most asked facts in Indian polity: the First Amendment, the Ninth Schedule, the Golaknath and Kesavananda judgments, the basic structure doctrine, and Article 300A.
1. Which constitutional amendment removed the right to property from the list of fundamental rights?
2. Under which Article is the right to property protected today?
3. Which amendment added the Ninth Schedule to the Constitution?
4. In which case did the Supreme Court lay down the basic structure doctrine?
5. What is the status of the right to property in India today?
6. What did the Supreme Court hold in the I. R. Coelho case (2007)?
7. In which year did the Supreme Court decide the Golaknath case?
8. Which law replaced the colonial Land Acquisition Act of 1894?